top of page

Are Corporations Managing Working Capital or Merely Financing It?

1 day ago
6 min read

The Capital Productivity Imperative | Part Two

Why achieving corporate capital efficiency requires more than managing individual financial functions.


A CFO's Challenge: From 19.5% to 16%


I recently had a conversation with a corporate CFO who described a straightforward but ambitious financial objective.


His organization wanted to reduce the working capital deployed in its business from approximately 19.5% of annual sales to 16%.


That conversation stayed with me.


Not because the objective was unusual, but because it illustrated an important distinction between managing working capital and improving corporate capital productivity.


Consider the potential economics.


For a company generating $8 billion in annual revenue, reducing working capital requirements by 3.5 percentage points of sales would represent approximately $280 million in capital released.


No incremental revenue required. No improvement in operating margins assumed. Just a reduction in the capital required to support the same level of business activity.


Of course, the improvement is not free. Achieving it may involve operational investment, financing costs, changes in commercial relationships and execution risk.


And the economic value of releasing capital depends on how that capital is subsequently deployed.


Nevertheless, the financial objective is compelling.


The question is not simply how to finance working capital more efficiently. It is how much capital the corporation should need in the first place.


The Difference Between Managing Working Capital and Optimizing Capital Productivity


Most large corporations already have sophisticated financial management capabilities.

Treasury manages liquidity, financing costs and financial risk.


Procurement negotiates purchasing economics and supplier relationships.


Sales organizations establish customer terms and commercial priorities.


Operations manages inventory, production and distribution.


Finance monitors working capital performance, cash conversion cycles and returns on invested capital.


Each function has legitimate objectives and established performance metrics.

But consider a fundamental question:


If every function achieves its individual objectives, does that necessarily mean the corporation has optimized its overall capital requirements?


Not always.


A procurement organization may negotiate longer supplier payment terms, improving its own cash flow while creating financial pressure elsewhere in the supply chain.


A sales organization may grow revenue by offering generous customer payment terms, increasing capital consumption even as commercial performance improves.


An operations team may maintain higher inventory levels to protect customer service, without fully evaluating the financial cost of that decision or alternative approaches to achieving resilience.


And treasury may evaluate a financing solution primarily through its cost, without fully considering its potential impact on commercial profitability or capital redeployment.

These decisions may each be rational within their respective functions.


Collectively, however, they may produce a capital structure for the operating cycle that is less efficient than it could be.


This is where the opportunity begins.



What Would It Actually Take to Reach 16%?


Returning to the CFO's objective, moving from 19.5% to 16% requires more than setting a financial target.


It requires identifying the opportunities available throughout the corporation's commercial operating cycle.


Traditional operational improvements remain essential.


Better inventory forecasting can reduce excess stock. More effective collections can improve receivables performance. Thoughtful payment term management can improve liquidity while protecting supplier relationships.


But should the assessment stop there?


Financial supply chain solutions can also contribute, provided their economic and accounting implications are properly understood.


Receivables finance may accelerate access to liquidity and, where the transaction qualifies for sale accounting, reduce recognized receivables without creating an equivalent borrowing liability.


Payables finance may enable suppliers to receive payment earlier while allowing buyers to manage agreed payment terms. The resulting economic benefits depend on financing costs, commercial terms, supplier participation and appropriate accounting treatment.


Inventory finance may provide alternative funding or ownership structures for inventory, although its impact on reported working capital depends on the contractual arrangement, transfer of risks and applicable accounting standards.


Dynamic discounting may allow a corporation with available liquidity to improve purchasing margins by offering suppliers accelerated payment in exchange for economically attractive discounts.


Not every solution will be appropriate for every company.


Importantly, financing an asset does not automatically reduce the economic capital required to operate the business. Nor does a favorable accounting presentation necessarily represent a genuine improvement in capital efficiency.


The objective must be to identify measurable economic value, not simply improve a reported metric.


That distinction should be central to the CFO's analysis.


The Questions a CFO Should Ask


I you are an experienced CFO, you might reasonably respond:


"We already manage working capital across the enterprise. We track DSO, DIO and DPO. Our treasury and operations teams understand the importance of capital efficiency. What are you suggesting we aren't already doing?"


It's a fair challenge.


I am not suggesting that corporate finance organizations have overlooked working capital management.


I am suggesting that measuring performance and comprehensively evaluating the available opportunities to improve capital productivity are not necessarily the same thing.


Four questions deserve consideration.


1. Capital Efficiency

Have we systematically identified the operational and financial alternatives that could reduce the capital our business needs to support its commercial activity?


2. Capital Redeployment

If we release capital, what is its economic value? Could it reduce financing expense, support profitable investment, strengthen the balance sheet or fund growth?


3. Financial Resilience

Would our proposed working capital strategy remain effective during economic disruption? Are we strengthening our liquidity position without increasing vulnerabilities among critical suppliers and customers?


4. Margin Enhancement

Are we treating liquidity exclusively as a financing resource, or are we also considering how payment timing and appropriately structured financial solutions could improve commercial profitability?


These questions extend the analysis beyond individual working capital metrics.


They bring the discussion closer to enterprise capital allocation.


The Danger of Optimizing One Balance Sheet at Another's Expense


There is another complication.


Every corporation participates in the commercial supply chain as both a buyer and a supplier.


A company that improves its own working capital performance by extending payment terms may simply transfer financing requirements to its suppliers.


That can look attractive when viewed through the buyer's financial statements.

But what happens if those suppliers face higher financing costs, weaker liquidity or reduced capacity to invest in their operations?


Some of those costs may eventually return to the buyer through higher prices, reduced flexibility or greater supply chain risk.


This is why sustainable working capital strategies should consider economic outcomes across trading relationships.


Appropriately structured supply chain finance programs can help address this challenge by allowing participants to access liquidity on terms that may be more attractive than their alternatives.


But the presence of financing alone does not guarantee mutual benefit.


The goal should be to improve the allocation and productivity of capital across the commercial ecosystem, rather than simply relocate the financial burden.


A Challenge to Banks and Fintech Providers


The supply chain finance industry has spent decades developing increasingly sophisticated products and platforms.


We can finance receivables, support payables, fund inventory and automate payments with extraordinary efficiency.


These capabilities are valuable, but perhaps our industry should reconsider the conversations that precede their introduction.


What if we began with the CFO's financial objectives rather than a financing product?

What if the first question were:


"How much capital is your business committing to its operating cycle, and what would it be worth to reduce that requirement?"


The next questions would follow naturally.


Where is capital unnecessarily committed?


Which improvements are operational, and which require financial solutions?


What is the net economic benefit after costs, risks and implementation requirements?


How will the proposed strategy affect suppliers, customers and the resilience of the broader supply chain?


And who within the organization is accountable for delivering the result?


These are strategic questions that should guide the selection of financing solutions and technology platforms. Not the other way around.


Perhaps We Are Starting the Conversation in the Wrong Place


The CFO I spoke with was not asking for another financing product.


He was describing a capital productivity objective.


Moving from 19.5% to 16% of sales represented a meaningful financial ambition, one that could potentially release substantial capital for more productive purposes.

Whether that target is achievable depends on the company's operating model, commercial relationships, existing performance and available improvement opportunities.


But the broader lesson is clear.


Working capital efficiency should not be measured solely by how effectively a corporation finances its operating cycle. It should also be measured by how economically that operating cycle consumes capital.


For corporations, this requires connecting financial objectives to operational and commercial decisions.


For banks and fintech providers, it creates an opportunity to move beyond product delivery toward helping clients achieve measurable economic outcomes.

Perhaps the next stage of growth in supply chain finance will not come from introducing another product.


Perhaps it will come from helping corporations answer a more fundamental question.


How much capital should our business actually require, and what would it be worth to operate with less?


That is a conversation worth having.


About SCF Strategies

SCF Strategies is an independent advisory firm focused on helping corporations, financial institutions and fintech providers unlock economic value through working capital optimization, financial supply chain solutions and commercial strategy.

Our approach begins with understanding financial and commercial objectives, identifying opportunities and evaluating solutions based on measurable economic outcomes.


This article is part of our ongoing series, The Capital Productivity Imperative, expanding on the themes introduced in our white paper, The Untapped Value of Working Capital Efficiency.

For more information or to continue the conversation, visit www.scfstrategies.com.


Comments


bottom of page